Skip to main content

Share

The ongoing Syrian civil war raises new cartographic challenges, including the ethical question of how the self-proclaimed Islamic State should be represented. States and news organizations face a conundrum: by mapping IS territory, they implicitly acknowledge its statehood. I investigate how different mapping methods carry different connotations for representing the strength and nature of the terror state, arguing that the statehood the IS is symbolically contested through cartographic choices that reflect the diverging interests of map makers.

Based on a comparative study, this article investigates the visual languages of IS sanctuary maps as published by news agencies, intelligence agencies, or circulated by the insurgents themselves. I argue that the statehood of territory held by the IS is symbolically contested through cartographic choices that reflect the diverging interests of the map makers. Beyond official representations, the article also considers the maps created by amateur conflict mappers and visual forensics experts, who extract and cross-reference information from social media including posted cell phone and drone footage, georeferenced tweets, and satellite images. I argue that the novel visual strategies developed by these practitioners for presenting visual evidence emphasize nonrepresentational aspects of cartography and represent a countermodel to established cartographic languages that follows an indexical rather than iconic or symbolic paradigm.

Offenhuber, D. (2017). Maps of Daesh: The Cartographic Warfare Surrounding Insurgent Statehood. GeoHumanities 4/1, 1–24.

Link PDF

Image: based on IS sanctuary map by Institute of Study of War, Azam Majooni

Related News

Image courtesy of Jonathan Wiggs/Globe Staff

Museum of Science hosts climate change education event

April 26, 2025

Learn More

Design students showcase exhibit at Milan Design Week

April 17, 2025

Learn More
Group picture in ISEC. Clockwise from top left: Chloe Hudson Prock, Paolo Ciuccarelli, Elizabeth McCaffrey and Jasmine Yiming Sun

Paolo Ciuccarelli works with Lexus for Milan Design Week exhibit

April 8, 2025

Learn More